Skip to content
Free Shipping on orders over $200
Search
Search our store
Search
Search
Search our store
Close search
Cart
0
Search
Search
Search our store
New
Dog
Destroyer
Prickles & Pricklets
ToysAhoy!
Snuggler
Backwoods Buddies
Muttley Crew
Pastel Softies
Playful Pairs
Thinker
Patches
Pockets
Tugger
Chubbie Tuggers
Tug-O-Sticks
The Greybars
The Weens
All Dog Toys
Cat
Cat Collections
Catnip Duos
Interchangeable Wands
Scratchers
Natural Wands
All Cat Toys
Seasonal
Christmas
Spring
Halloween
Valentine's
St. Patty's
About us
FAQ
Contact us
Shipping Policies
About us
Sale
New
Dog
Destroyer
Prickles & Pricklets
ToysAhoy!
Snuggler
Backwoods Buddies
Muttley Crew
Pastel Softies
Playful Pairs
Thinker
Patches
Pockets
Tugger
Chubbie Tuggers
Tug-O-Sticks
The Greybars
The Weens
All Dog Toys
Cat
Cat Collections
Catnip Duos
Interchangeable Wands
Scratchers
Natural Wands
All Cat Toys
Seasonal
Christmas
Spring
Halloween
Valentine's
St. Patty's
About us
FAQ
Contact us
Shipping Policies
About us
Sale
More links
Search
Search
Search our store
Cart
0
Home
Right
15% off for new customers
15% off for new customers
Filter
Sort
Filter by
Clear
Sort by
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Title, A-Z
Title, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Apply
Clear all
217 products
Quick buy
More details
Prickles with Tomato and Mozzarella Cheese Ball 5"
$6.00
Quick buy
More details
Seahorse 11"
$5.40
Quick buy
More details
Corduroy Snowman with Hat 15"
$4.75
Quick buy
More details
Squirrel in a Present Prickle Ball 5"
$7.95
Quick buy
More details
Sold Out
Franklin the Frog 8"
$6.95
Sold Out
Quick buy
More details
Elephant Stick 20"
$6.35
Quick buy
More details
Pastel Unicorn 15"
$9.90
Quick buy
More details
Bear Greybar
$3.50
Quick buy
More details
Pricklet Elephant 4"
$5.40
Quick buy
More details
Koala Greybar 6"
$3.50
Quick buy
More details
Winter Wolf 24"
$10.25
Quick buy
More details
Frog Greybar 6"
$3.50
« Previous
1
…
4
5
6
7
8
…
19
Next »
×
Shipping Notice
Please note: This item is scheduled to ship between September 1 and October 1, 2026.
I UNDERSTAND
